1`

9 Composting Lies Every Gardener Needs to Stop Believing

Composting sounds like such a no-brainer, doesn’t it? Toss your scraps and yard waste into a pile, wait a little while, and voilà—free fertilizer. But somehow, it’s surrounded by all these myths that make it feel way harder or messier than it really is. I’ve heard it all—“It smells terrible,” “It’s too complicated,” “You need a huge yard.” Spoiler: none of those are true.

The reality? Composting can be as simple or as involved as you want it to be, and it’s not nearly as gross or intimidating as people make it sound. Once you ditch the misinformation, composting becomes a straightforward, budget-friendly way to boost your garden. Let’s look at the most common lies and get you set up for composting success.

Compost Kills Weed Seeds

Image Credit: Viktor Sergeevich/ Shutterstock.

Hot composting can kill weed seeds, but it’s not a magic fix. For it to work, your pile has to hit at least 140°F for several days, and even then, those seeds need to stay in the hot center—not the cooler edges. If you’re not managing your pile regularly, some seeds might still survive.

To play it safe, trim weeds before they go to seed and let them dry out completely in the sun before tossing them in. Or skip the compost pile altogether and use weeds as fertilizer by soaking them in water to create a nutrient-rich tea for your plants.

Composting Requires Perfect Ratios

Image Credit: Ladanifer/ Shutterstock.

Some composting guides make it sound like you need a precise recipe to get it right. While there are “perfect” ratios out there, most gardeners don’t have the time or patience to follow them. And honestly? You don’t need to. Composting works just fine with a mix of moist greens (like veggie peels) and dry browns (like leaves or cardboard).

Think of composting as a forgiving process. Keep it balanced, give it a stir now and then, and nature will take care of the rest. Overthinking it will only make it feel like a chore, and no one has time for that.

Kitchen Scraps Don’t Have to Be Messy

Image Credit: Halfpoint/ Shutterstock.

The idea of storing kitchen scraps might make you cringe, but it doesn’t have to be gross. A countertop compost bin is your best friend here. There are cute, compact options that blend right into your kitchen, and many come with filters to keep smells at bay.

For easy cleanup, try biodegradable liners you can toss straight into the compost pile. They save you from scrubbing the bin every week, and they make collecting scraps feel way less like a hassle.

Composting Works Only Works In Large Spaces

Image Credit: Adobe Stock

Think you need a sprawling backyard to compost? Not true. Compact compost bins can fit into even the smallest spaces. There are options designed for balconies, patios, or even a corner of your kitchen. They’re perfect for urban gardeners or anyone working with a small footprint.

Some of these bins, like stackable models, make it super easy to compost without taking up valuable real estate. So, don’t let lack of space stop you from giving it a try—it’s more doable than you might think.

You Can Only Compost Outside

Image Credit: Andriana Syvanych/ Shutterstock.

Outdoor composting is great, but it’s not the only option. Vermicomposting (composting with worms) is a fantastic indoor solution. If worms aren’t your thing, there are electric composters that heat and aerate scraps, giving you finished compost in no time without stepping foot outside.

These indoor methods are mess-free and smell-free, so you won’t have to worry about gross odors taking over your home. They’re a great way to compost year-round, whether you have outdoor space or not.

Compost Stinks

Image Credit: Antonio Guillem/ Shutterstock.

A lot of people shy away from composting because they think it’ll make their space smell like rotting garbage. If you’re working with a small garden or patio, the last thing you want is for your compost pile to be the smelly neighbor. But here’s the deal: compost only stinks if it’s not done right.

A healthy compost pile should actually smell like fresh soil after a rain—kind of earthy and clean. To get there, keep your pile balanced with greens (like kitchen scraps) and browns (like dry leaves), and don’t let it get too wet. If you’re doing it right, bad smells won’t even be on your radar.

Bugs and Rodents Are Guaranteed

Image Credit: Tomasz Klejdysz/Shutterstock.com

Yes, bugs and critters might find your compost interesting, but that’s not always a bad thing. Some insects are actually a sign that your compost is working—think worms and pill bugs. They’re like tiny helpers speeding up the process. But if the idea of creepy crawlies makes your skin crawl, there are ways to keep the party contained.

Make sure you’re not throwing things like meat, dairy, or oily food into your pile. Those are basically open invites for rodents. Enclosed compost bins or tumblers are lifesavers here. They’ll keep the pests out while still letting the good bugs do their thing.

Composting Is Tricky

Image Credit: nieriss/ Shutterstock.

If you’ve ever read a composting guide that felt more like a science experiment, don’t let it scare you off. Sure, you can dive into ratios and temperatures if you’re the meticulous type, but honestly, composting can be as simple as tossing your scraps into a bin.

The basics? Mix about equal parts green stuff (like veggie peels) and brown stuff (like cardboard). Keep it moist but not soaked, and give it a stir every now and then. That’s it. You don’t need to overthink it to get great results.

It Takes Forever

Image Credit: grandbrothers/ Shutterstock.

One of the biggest complaints about composting is how long it takes. Who wants to wait months or even years for a pile of scraps to turn into usable compost? The thing is, it doesn’t have to take that long.

If you’re in a hurry, look into hot composting methods like the Berkeley method. With the right mix of materials and a little effort, you can have finished compost in less than three weeks. But even if you take the slow route, the payoff—a constant supply of free, nutrient-rich soil—is absolutely worth it.

*This content was created with the assistance of AI.

Author

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top