We all have moments when we look back on a decision and ask ourselves, “What on earth was I thinking?” For some, this might be a cringe-inducing fashion choice or a questionable haircut. For others, like myself, these moments often revolve around renovation decisions, specifically painting over something that, in retrospect, should have been left alone.
Let’s go on a therapeutic journey, a list of 12 things I wish I’d never painted over. I hope my lessons can save you from some future regret!
1. Original Woodwork
Preserving original woodwork can be a gateway to maintaining the historic charm and dignity of a home. I made the mistake of painting over the beautifully aged oak trim in my living room, believing that a fresh coat of white paint would give it a modern touch. But instead, I found myself missing the character and warmth that the original wood brought to the space.
In the future, before you reach for the paintbrush, consider alternative ways to freshen up your woodwork. You could try cleaning and re-staining it for a refreshed look that maintains its original appeal. And remember, once painted, it’s incredibly difficult (and often impossible) to restore woodwork to its original state.
2. Brick Fireplace
My old brick fireplace had a rustic appeal that added a cozy feel to my living room. But in a misguided attempt to modernize, I painted it sleek black. While it did look more contemporary, it lost its inviting warmth.
If you’re in a similar situation, consider a less permanent solution. You could use a removable paint or a limewash, which can be removed if you change your mind later. Also, consider the impact on the room’s overall atmosphere before making a drastic change.
3. Antique Furniture
In the wake of the “shabby chic” trend, I fell into the trap of painting a gorgeous antique dresser that had been in my family for generations. The distressed white paint job made it trendy, but it lost its nostalgic charm and history.
Before you pull out the paint, consider the value of the piece—not just in monetary terms but also sentimental. Sometimes, a good cleaning and minor repairs are all that’s needed to make an old piece shine again.
4. Stained Glass
In an attempt to add some privacy, I painted over a beautiful stained glass window in my front door. I soon realized that I had not only blocked out the colorful light but also damaged the intricate artistry of the glass.
Stained glass is a unique feature that adds value to your home. If privacy is an issue, consider using a window film or blinds instead of paint. This provides the privacy you need without permanently damaging the glass.
5. Vintage Wallpaper
Thinking that the floral vintage wallpaper in my dining room was outdated, I painted over it. However, I later discovered that vintage wallpaper can be a coveted feature and its removal can sometimes reveal the pristine walls beneath.
Before painting over wallpaper, consider its potential value. If it’s in good condition and adds a unique charm to your space, it might be worth preserving.
6. Original Tilework
In a fit of renovation enthusiasm, I painted over the original tilework in my bathroom. I later realized that the original tiles had a unique charm that the modern, painted-over ones lacked.
Original tilework, especially in older homes, can significantly contribute to the character of a room. Before you paint over it, consider cleaning or re-grouting the tiles to refresh their look instead.
7. Ceiling Medallions
I once painted a ceiling medallion the same color as the rest of the ceiling, thinking it would give a seamless look. However, I soon realized that the medallion lost its stunning detail when it wasn’t contrasted against the ceiling.
If you’re lucky enough to have ceiling medallions in your home, let them stand out. They’re a unique architectural feature that adds historical charm to any space.
8. Hardwood Floors
I painted my hardwood floors white for a Scandinavian-inspired look. But the charm quickly faded when the paint began to chip and the beautiful wood grain was lost forever.
If you have quality hardwood floors, embrace their natural beauty. They’re durable, timeless, and can be refinished numerous times to fit your changing aesthetic.
9. Wrought Iron
I once decided to paint my black wrought iron railing a trendy turquoise. It looked great for about a week until the paint started chipping and the iron began to rust.
Wrought iron is a durable material that looks beautiful with its natural patina. So, before you decide to paint it, consider alternatives like powder coating, which can provide color while preserving the integrity of the iron.
10. Marble Countertops
In an attempt to follow a trend, I painted my marble countertops a solid white. I soon regretted this decision as I missed the luxurious look and feel of the natural stone.
Marble is a beautiful, natural material that adds value to your home. If you’re not a fan of the color or pattern of your marble countertops, consider replacing them rather than painting them.
11. Vintage Metal Hardware
Thinking that my vintage brass door knobs looked dated, I painted them modern silver. It didn’t take long to realize that I’d made a mistake by covering up their unique charm.
Before you paint over vintage hardware, consider their potential value. Many people appreciate the character of older pieces, and they can often be cleaned or polished to restore their original beauty.
12. Stone Walls
I once painted a natural stone wall in my home, thinking it would brighten the space. However, the paint dulled the rich textures and colors of the stone, and I found myself missing its organic appeal.
If you’re lucky enough to have stone walls in your home, embrace their natural beauty. They add texture, warmth, and a unique architectural element that is hard to replicate. If you want to brighten the space, consider using lighting or decor instead.